Daily Review Archive

04 September 2026

Review calendar

10 Amber Room Reviews

Amber Room Review

Auld Alliance Saburomaru 2019 2023 59,65%

Saburomaru
88
Auld Alliance Saburomaru 2019 2023 59,65% — bottle label
Auld Alliance Saburomaru 2019 2023 59,65% — bottle label
Auld Alliance Saburomaru 2019 2023 59,65% — bottle label

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Auld Alliance
ABV
59.65%
Vintage
2019
Bottled
2023
Bottles in release
185

Nose

A very pleasant & gentle nose despite the high ABV, tropical fruits, creamy, does not smell heavily peated at all

Body

The palate definitely packs a punch & is very reflective of the youthfulness (runs quite hot & spicy), quite sweet but becomes spicier towards the end

Finish

Long & slightly bitter finish, there’s a subtle linger smokiness but it’s VERY subtle

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Hanyu 1986 2008 Cask #2812 58,4%

Hanyu
90
Hanyu 1986 2008 Cask #2812 58,4% — bottle label
Illustrative image · Illustrative bottle photo: Hanyu Closed Distilleries. Representative of the reviewed product line; the exact reviewed release is not confirmed by this image.
Illustrative imageIllustrative bottle photo: Hanyu Closed Distilleries. Representative of the reviewed product line; the exact reviewed release is not confirmed by this image.

Whisky facts

Bottling type
Official Bottling
Age
22 years
ABV
58.4%
Vintage
1986
Bottled
2008
Cask number
2812
Bottles in release
305

Not a bad whisky by any means but for the price and reputation of this distillery, I am not that impressed

Nose

Quite a subtle peated nose but also surprisingly sweet, initially fresh fruits but gets increasingly darker

Body

Definitely a lot of oomph but surprisingly hot for a 22yo whisky, prunes, dark fruits, surprisingly sweet with water added, but also gets spicier

Finish

Slightly bitter finish, shorter than I expected although the bitterness does linger

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

SMWS 116.5 'Euthymol smokers' toothpaste' Yoichi 1986 2005 18 Years Old 50,5%

Yoichi
90
Client photo: SMWS 116.5, Jul 1986/Jun 2005, 18 years, with glass; bottle top cut off. 50.5% confirmed by Bar K catalogue.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
SMWS
Age
18 years
ABV
50.5%
Vintage
1986
Bottled
2005

A very complex dram that is hampered by the finish

Nose

Honestly if I had to blind this I would have thought that its a sherried Islay with a very delicate balance between sweet & smokiness, slightly floral

Body

The palate reminds me of a 1970s Ardbeg with its initial sweetness before the gentle but very obvious smokiness arrives, finished with a slightly bitter & linger aftertaste With water it becomes sweeter but also slightly more spicy towards the end, the smoke is very subtle and is concentrated more in the aftertaste

Finish

Slightly dry & spicy finish

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Cadenhead 175th Anniversary Banff 1976 2017 40 Years Old 51,2%

Banff
90
Client-supplied Cadenhead 175th Anniversary Banff 1976/2017, 40 years, 51.2%; dates corroborated by the exact inspected auction catalogue.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Cadenhead
Age
40 years
ABV
51.2%
Vintage
1976
Bottled
2017

Nose

Orchard fruits, herbal tea, sweet, quite a fresh nose, slightly tart-like

Body

Very full palate, definitely sweet, zesty, slightly bitter & spicy towards the end, peaches

Finish

Lingering tropical fruits finish, slightly oaky but not bitter; surprisingly there’s a bit of smokiness towards the end which is a very welcoming surprise

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

The Auld Alliance Dornoch 2017 8 Years Old 52,3%

Dornoch
—Not scored
The Auld Alliance Dornoch 2017 8 Years Old 52,3% — bottle label
The Auld Alliance Dornoch 2017 8 Years Old 52,3% — bottle label
The Auld Alliance Dornoch 2017 8 Years Old 52,3% — bottle label

Whisky facts

Region
Highland
Independent Bottler
Auld Alliance
Age
8 years
ABV
52.3%
Bottles in release
77

This was my first Dornoch ever and quite honestly I am blown away & very pleasantly surprised of the quality of the dram

Nose

Beautiful nose, would have never guessed that this was an 8yo whisky, so floral & fragrant I could honestly smell this all day, extremely fresh & fruity

Body

Sweet & does not taste young at all, very fruity, apricot, salted plums, a very interesting profile, even have some umami funkiness

Finish

Long, sweet, slightly salty & dry finish

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

The Auld Alliance Heavily Peated Tomintoul 2001 2015 52,1%

Tomintoul
—Not scored
The Auld Alliance Heavily Peated Tomintoul 2001 2015 52,1% — bottle label
Illustrative image · Illustrative client label photo: Auld Alliance/Three Rivers heavily peated Speyside 2001/2015, 52.1%; distillery line faded.
Illustrative imageIllustrative client label photo: Auld Alliance/Three Rivers heavily peated Speyside 2001/2015, 52.1%; distillery line faded.

Whisky facts

Region
Speyside
Independent Bottler
Auld Alliance
Age
14 years
ABV
52.1%
Vintage
2001
Bottled
2015
Cask type
Refill Hogshead
Bottles in release
220

It’s not everyday you come across a young heavily peated Tomintoul, definitely had to try this considering that I’ve only drank really old 40+yo Tomintouls before. A young whisky but not bad by any means, a good budget Speyside option

Nose

Definitely a very fresh, fruity nose, no signs of peat, slightly floral, very sweet nose

Body

The peatiness comes hard in the palate, lots of smoke, then comes the sweetness, honey, burnt sugars

Finish

Lingering smoke in the finish, long & slightly salty finish, gets a bit bitter towards the very end but not too noticable

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

The Auld Alliance Port Ellen 1983 32 Years Old 54% Cask 001/508

Port Ellen
90
Illustrative image · Illustrative bottle photo: Port Ellen Auld Alliance. Representative of the reviewed product line; the exact reviewed release is not confirmed by this image.
Illustrative image · Illustrative client photo: Auld Alliance Port Ellen 1983, 32y, cask 001/508; strength unreadable.
Illustrative imageIllustrative client photo: Auld Alliance Port Ellen 1983, 32y, cask 001/508; strength unreadable.
Illustrative image

Whisky facts

Region
Islay
Independent Bottler
Auld Alliance
Age
32 years
ABV
54%
Vintage
1983
Cask number
001/508
Bottles in release
120

From one of the last barrels of Port Ellen. An above average Port Ellen with a gentle, balanced peatiness but it feels closer to a Caol Ila than a typical Port Ellen

Nose

Definitely a more meaty Port Ellen, closer to a Caol Ila nose than a typical Port Ellen, opens up to a more ashy, lemony sensation with hints of saltiness

Body

Initially quite sweet but quickly becomes briny and then slightly spicy, zesty, big meaty peatiness followed by industrial coal & ashes, a typical Port Ellen profile (not like that’s bad or anything), alot of salty maritime peatiness, but a very subtle & elegant level of peat

Finish

Long smoky finish, but the lingering smoke is quite gentle, slightly spicy

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Auld Alliance Bushmills 1991 2024 32 Years Old 43,4% Cask 8393

Bushmills
90
Auld Alliance Bushmills 1991 2024 32 Years Old 43,4% Cask 8393 — bottle label
Illustrative image · Illustrative bottle photo: Bushmills single malt Irish whiskey. Representative of the reviewed product line; the exact reviewed release is not confirmed by this image.
Illustrative imageIllustrative bottle photo: Bushmills single malt Irish whiskey. Representative of the reviewed product line; the exact reviewed release is not confirmed by this image.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Auld Alliance
Age
32 years
ABV
43.4%
Vintage
1991
Bottled
2024
Cask type
Barrel
Cask number
8393
Bottles in release
95

A solid 30+ yo Irish whiskey that I wish could have had a bit more oomph perhaps at 50% or higher

Nose

Very fragnant floral fresh fruity nose, acrylic, quite sweet, cane sugars, rum-like

Body

Very floral & sweet, gets a bit tropical, definitely mangoes, almost perfumy but not quite there (thank god), definitely rum-like (not surprised from my previous Irish experience), gets slightly spicy towards the end but nothing too overwhelming

Finish

Short, slightly dry, sweet finish, more tropical fruity lingering notes

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Michael Wigman “They Inspired II” Ardmore 1988 2021 32 Years Old 48,6%

Ardmore
87
Illustrative image · Illustrative client photo: Wigman They Inspired II Ardmore, bottled Jan 2021, 48.6%; vintage and age unreadable.
Ardmore 1988/2021 They Inspired II series 2.2, supplied foreground bottle photograph
Ardmore 1988/2021 They Inspired II series 2.2, supplied foreground bottle photograph
Illustrative image

Whisky facts

Region
Highland
Independent Bottler
Michael Wigman
Age
32 years
ABV
48.6%
Vintage
1988
Bottled
2021
Bottles in release
192

Nose

Fresh fruits, floral, very light & elegant nose, melons, vanilla

Body

Definitely sweet, honey and vanilla, runs slightly spicy & hot towards the end

Finish

Slightly lingering bitter & dry finish

Open Whisky Page