Daily Review Archive

09 November 2026

Review calendar

12 Amber Room Reviews

Amber Room Review

Bladnoch Forum Port Ellen 1982 2006 24 Years Old 60,4% Cask 2461

Port Ellen
89.5
Client photograph: Bladnoch Forum Port Ellen 1982 2006 24 Years Old 60,4% Cask 2461.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Bladnoch Forum
Age
24 years
ABV
60.4%
Vintage
1982
Bottled
2006
Cask number
2461

Nose

Coal, ash, industrial smoke, briny, a bit zesty but not too apparent, intense nose, definitely smells like a 60% whisky

Body

Quite sweet for a Port Ellen, but gets spicier over time, zesty, again with the industrial smoke, quite earthy and coal; with water it gets a bit sweeter but still quite spicy and even a bit oaky towards the end

Finish

Long, salty finish, liquorice, slightly bitter, tar & ashy

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Douglas Laing Old Malt Cask Port Ellen 1978 2005 27 Years Old 52,3% bottled for The Whisky Fair

Port Ellen
91
Client photograph: Douglas Laing Old Malt Cask Port Ellen 1978 2005 27 Years Old 52,3% bottled for The Whisky Fair.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Douglas Laing
Age
27 years
ABV
52.3%
Vintage
1978
Bottled
2005

Nose

Typical Port Ellen nose, ashes, coal, smoky but an elegant kind of smoke, zesty, gets a bit meaty after a bit of time in the glass

Body

Sweet, briny, zesty, coal, a lot of oomph and smoke, with water it gets sweeter and more zesty, the smoke is somewhat enhanced towards the end

Finish

Long smoky & zesty finish, gets a bit spicy and dry towards the end

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Sansibar Spirits Shop' Selection Speyside 1977 2015 38 Years Old 46,1%

89
Client photograph: Sansibar Spirits Shop' Selection Speyside 1977 2015 38 Years Old 46,1%.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Sansibar
Age
38 years
ABV
46.1%
Vintage
1977
Bottled
2015

Nose

Typical old sherried style nose, dried fruits, prunes, dates, orange jam, sweet

Body

Dried fruits, prunes, dates, sweet, bitter oranges, gets a bit spicy towards the end, a balanced sherried dram, not too sweet and not too over-rippened

Finish

Medium finish, sweet, grapy, honey, slightly dry & spicy towards the end

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

The Auld Alliance Lochside 1981 37 Years Old 48,6%

Lochside
86
Client photograph of a tasting sample: The Auld Alliance Lochside 1981 37 Years Old 48,6%.

Tasting sample photo

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
The Auld Alliance
Age
37 years
ABV
48.6%
Vintage
1981

Nose

Quite an interesting nose, a bit grassy and herbal, almost towards dill

Body

Starts off sweet but gets increasingly bitter and sour, a bit too floral and borderline perfumy

Finish

Long bitter, floral finish

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

The Whiskyfind Ben Nevis 1999 2025 26 Years Old 46,1%

Ben Nevis
88
Client photograph: The Whiskyfind Ben Nevis 1999 2025 26 Years Old 46,1%.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
The Whiskyfind
Age
26 years
ABV
46.1%
Vintage
1999
Bottled
2025

Nose

Banana pudding cake, very creamy, oily, very sweet & pleasant nose

Body

The body is still quite fruity but gets slightly bitter, guavas, bitter oranges, sweet but fades away quite quickly

Finish

Medium fruity finish, not as sweet as I expected, a bit floral

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Rare Malts Royal Brackla 1978 1998 20 Years Old 59,8%

Royal Brackla
89
Client photograph: Rare Malts Royal Brackla 1978 1998 20 Years Old 59,8%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Rare Malts Royal Brackla 1978 1998 20 Years Old 59,8%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Rare Malts Royal Brackla 1978 1998 20 Years Old 59,8%.

Whisky facts

Bottling type
Official Bottling
Age
20 years
ABV
59.8%
Vintage
1978
Bottled
1998

Nose

Tropical fruits, citrus, vanilla, quite an easy nose for a high ABV whisky

Body

Sweet, honey, caramel, fruity, apples, oranges, cider, slightly spicy towards the end, one of the easier to drink Rare Malts that I've had, does not need water to dilute it down to a drinkable state; with water it becomes sweeter and fruitier, the orange is more pronounced

Finish

Long, zesty finish

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Bowmore 30 Years Old Sea Dragon 43%

Bowmore
89
Client photograph: Bowmore 30 Years Old Sea Dragon 43%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Bowmore 30 Years Old Sea Dragon 43%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Bowmore 30 Years Old Sea Dragon 43%.

Whisky facts

Bottling type
Official Bottling
Age
30 years
ABV
43%

Nose

A Bowmore fruitbomb, mangoes, guavas, melons, passion fruits

Body

Sweet, again very fruity, tropical fruits, melons, tea, a bit floral towards the end

Finish

Slightly short finish, sweet and fruity until the end

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Mackillop's Choice Blair Athol 1973 2004 30 Years old 43%

Blair Athol
87
Client photograph: Mackillop's Choice Blair Athol 1973 2004 30 Years old 43%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Mackillop's Choice Blair Athol 1973 2004 30 Years old 43%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Mackillop's Choice Blair Athol 1973 2004 30 Years old 43%.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Mackillop's Choice
Age
30 years
ABV
43%
Vintage
1973
Bottled
2004
Cask number
8569

Nose

Fresh fruits, honey, sweet, menthol, floral, tea, an amazing complex nose

Body

Slightly bitter, earthy, a bit oily, gets sweeter & fruity, woody

Finish

Short finish, oaky and slightly bitter

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Hart Brothers Talisker 1990 2002 12 Years Old 46%

Talisker
89
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Hart Brothers Talisker 1990 2002 12 Years Old 46%.

Tasting sample photo

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Hart Brothers
Age
12 years
ABV
46%
Vintage
1990
Bottled
2002

Nose

Banana pudding cake, a bit milky, very interesting nose for a Talisker, gets saltier and a bit creamy

Body

Salty, sweet, oranges, salted caramel, does not taste spicy at all despite the young age

Finish

Medium, slightly nutty finish with a hint of sulphur, the banana comes back

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Samaroli Glencadam 1985 2005 45%

Glencadam
88
Client photograph: Samaroli Glencadam 1985 2005 45%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Samaroli Glencadam 1985 2005 45%.
Client photograph of a tasting sample: Samaroli Glencadam 1985 2005 45%.

Whisky facts

Independent Bottler
Samaroli
ABV
45%
Vintage
1985
Bottled
2005

Nose

Sweet, honey, oranges, dried fruits, kumquats

Body

A bit oily, quite punchy despite the relatively low ABV, a hint of smoke, slightly salty, oranges

Finish

Short finish, slightly oaky, the finish is definitely the worst part of this dram

Open Whisky Page

Amber Room Review

Highland Park 30 48,1% bottled 2005

Highland Park
91
Client photograph: Highland Park 30 Years Old 48,1% bottled 2005.

Whisky facts

Bottling type
Official Bottling
Age
30 years
ABV
48.1%

Nose

Beautiful old sherried style nose, very elegant and balanced, sweet & creamy, dried fruits, honey, toffee, chocolates, oranges

Body

Bitter oranges, honey, sweet, creamy, a bit oily, slightly nutty, prunes, dates, grapy, ripe fruits

Finish

Long, sweet, slightly dry finish, dried fruits, meaty, gets a bit spicy towards the end

Open Whisky Page

Review 234

Milroy Ben Nevis 28 1996 51,8%

Ben Nevis
88.5
Illustrative image · Illustrative bottle photo: Ben Nevis Vintage Highland Reserve. Representative of the reviewed product line; the exact reviewed release is not confirmed by this image.
Client photograph: Milroy's Ben Nevis 1996 2025 28 Years Old 51,8%.
Client photograph: Milroy's Ben Nevis 1996 2025 28 Years Old 51,8%.
Illustrative image

Whisky facts

Region
Highland
Age
28 years
ABV
51.8%

Nose

Tropical fruits, apples, peaches, creamy, gently sweet

Body

Honey, quite sweet, salted caramel, tropical fruitbomb, creamy, a bit of lime towards the end

Finish

Medium finish, quite fruity but gets slightly oaky towards the end

Open Whisky Page