Daily Review Archive

13 January 2026

Review calendar

3 Amber Room Reviews

Review 035

Whiskyforyou Ardbeg 1991 2009 18 Years Old 50%

Ardbeg
91
Whiskyforyou Ardbeg 1991 2009 18 Years Old 50% — bottle label

Whisky facts

Region
Islay
Independent Bottler
Whiskyforyou
Age
18 years
ABV
50%
Vintage
1991
Bottled
2009
Bottles in release
120

Nose

Grilled meats, bbq, charcoal, firewoods

Body

Very meaty and smoky, bbq in your mouth, becomes a bit sweeter towards the end, surprisingly smooth for the age, medicinal and slightly salty

Finish

Long warm peaty finish

Open Whisky Page

Review 034

Cadenhead Small Batch Tomatin 1978 2014 35 Years Old 44,4%

Tomatin
89
Client photo: Cadenhead Tomatin, 35 years; bottle view.
Internet critic photo, source くりりん: Cadenhead Small Batch Tomatin 35, 44.4%, with glass and background bottles. Critic identifies 1978/2014; these years are not printed on the visible front label. Full frame.
Internet critic photo, source くりりん: Cadenhead Small Batch Tomatin 35, 44.4%, with glass and background bottles. Critic identifies 1978/2014; these years are not printed on the visible front label. Full frame.

Whisky facts

Region
Highland
Independent Bottler
Cadenhead
Age
35 years
ABV
44.4%
Vintage
1978
Bottled
2014

Nose

Tropical fruit bomb, funky, melons, bananas

Body

Menthol, more spicy than sweet, honey, creamy

Finish

Medium & dry finish, gets spicier & peppery over time

Open Whisky Page

Review 033

Highland Park 1967 1991 43%

Highland Park
88
Client photo: Highland Park 1967; bottle view.
Illustrative image · Illustrative client photo: Highland Park 21, 43%, green dumpy bottle with Ferraretto label and glass. A different edition from the reviewed 1967/1991 release. Whole original frame.
Illustrative imageIllustrative client photo: Highland Park 21, 43%, green dumpy bottle with Ferraretto label and glass. A different edition from the reviewed 1967/1991 release. Whole original frame.

Whisky facts

Region
Highland
Bottling type
Official Bottling
ABV
43%
Vintage
1967
Bottled
1991

A disappointing 1960s Highland Park bottled at a lackluster ABV

Nose

Oily, dried fruits, herbal

Body

Herbal, apples and dark oranges, slight smoke & spice towards the end, a bit thin (prob better at 48 or 50%)

Finish

Short finish, slightly waxy & salty

Open Whisky Page